What to check on a certificate of insurance before you accept it
A certificate of insurance is a snapshot, not a policy. What to check on a COI or certificate of currency before you accept it, and what it cannot show.
In short
A certificate of insurance (COI), called a certificate of currency in Australia and New Zealand, summarises insurance as at its date of issue. US regulators say it cannot change the policy. Check the named insured, insurer, policy numbers, types and limits of cover and the policy period against your contract. Ask for the endorsement if you must be an additional insured. Track the expiry date, and do not assume anyone will tell you if the policy is cancelled.
Before you accept a certificate of insurance, check five things against your contract: who is insured, by which insurer, for which types of cover, up to what limits and for what period. Then remember what the certificate cannot do. It is evidence, as at its date of issue, that the policies it lists were in force; it does not show the full policy terms.
This is general information to help you check documents, not legal or insurance advice. The sources below describe specific jurisdictions; the legal effect of a certificate depends on the policy, your contract and the law that applies.
What is a certificate of insurance, and what can it not do?
A certificate of insurance is a short summary of one or more policies, issued by the insurer or the broker who placed them. People use different names for it:
- United States and Canada: certificate of insurance, often shortened to COI.
- Australia and New Zealand: certificate of currency. Australian Defence guidance uses this term, and New Zealand insurers such as AA Insurance issue certificates of currency on request.
- United Kingdom: insurance certificate. For employers’ liability insurance, GOV.UK calls it an EL certificate.
Regulators describe clear limits. The Connecticut Insurance Department says a certificate serves as evidence of insurance “in lieu of an actual copy of an insurance policy”. It says a certificate “confers no rights or benefits upon the third party certificate holder” and “cannot be used to amend, expand or alter the terms” of the policy.
New York’s Department of Financial Services concluded in 2008 that a certificate may not confer new or additional rights beyond those in the policy. Australian Defence guidance says a certificate of currency is only evidence that a policy is in force at its date of issue. It does not give the full terms, conditions and exclusions, and where it differs from the policy, the policy terms will usually prevail.
What should you check on every certificate?
- Named insured. The insured’s legal name matches the entity you contract with, not just a trading name or a related company.
- Insurer. The insurer is named, not only the broker. In the UK, employers’ liability cover must come from an authorised insurer, which you can check on the Financial Conduct Authority register.
- Policy numbers. Each policy listed has a number you could quote to the insurer.
- Types of cover. The certificate lists every type your contract requires, for example general or public liability, professional indemnity, product liability, workers’ compensation or employers’ liability, and motor.
- Limits. Each limit meets your contract’s minimum, per occurrence and in aggregate where both apply. Read the limits with care (see below).
- Policy period. The effective and expiry dates cover the whole period of the work, or you have a plan to collect the renewal.
- Certificate holder. Your organisation’s name and address are correct.
- Additional insured or waiver wording. If your contract requires it, ask for the endorsement itself (see below).
- Issue date and issuer. The certificate is recent and comes from the insurer or broker, not retyped by the supplier.
What can the limits on a certificate not tell you?
Australian Defence guidance points out that limits shown on a certificate of currency are generally the limits at the start of the policy period. Claims since then may have reduced them. It also notes that a certificate issued to show compliance with a contract may state only the limit that contract requires, not the policy’s whole limit. Do not work out the full policy limit from a certificate; ask the broker or read the policy schedule if it matters.
Why is “additional insured” on the certificate not enough?
Because a certificate summarises cover; it does not create it. The Connecticut bulletin says a certificate does not make the holder an additional insured. That status comes from being named “by endorsement” or as an insured under the policy’s own terms. If your contract requires additional-insured status or a waiver of subrogation, ask your broker which policy terms or endorsements provide it. Then ask for a copy and check that it names you, or a class of parties that includes you.
Will anyone tell you if the policy is cancelled?
Do not assume so. The Connecticut bulletin states that a certificate holder “is owed no duty to be notified” if the policy is cancelled. Any right to notice would come from the policy, an endorsement, your contract with the supplier or the law that applies. Check those, not the certificate.
A certificate you accepted months ago does not show whether the policy is still in force today. Track the expiry date, ask for a fresh certificate at each renewal, and ask again before a large or risky job starts.
What do insurance documents look like in each country?
| Country | Document to ask for | Worth knowing |
|---|---|---|
| United States | Certificate of insurance (COI) | Connecticut and New York regulators say a certificate cannot change the policy or give the holder new rights. Ask for endorsements where your contract requires additional-insured status. |
| Canada | Certificate of insurance (COI) | In Ontario, a WSIB clearance relieves a principal of liability for certain amounts a contractor owes the WSIB, within limits set in WSIB policy. A clearance is valid for up to 90 calendar days and is renewable; construction has its own clearance policy. |
| United Kingdom | Insurance certificate; employers’ liability (EL) certificate | Employers generally need employers’ liability insurance of at least £5 million from an authorised insurer, and must display the certificate where employees can access it. Some employers are exempt; HSENI covers Northern Ireland. |
| Australia | Certificate of currency | Defence guidance: evidence that a policy is in force at the date of issue; where it differs from the policy, the policy terms will usually prevail. |
| New Zealand | Certificate of currency | New Zealand insurers such as AA Insurance issue them on request. Check the same fields, and ask for the policy wording when you need the terms and exclusions. |
How often should you ask for a new certificate?
These are suggested triggers, not legal requirements:
- At each policy renewal, using the expiry date on the current certificate. Defence guidance notes that most insurances renew annually.
- Before significant work starts, if the last certificate is more than a few months old.
- Whenever the supplier changes insurer, legal entity or the scope of work.
- For Ontario WSIB clearances, before the current clearance ends, since each is valid for up to 90 calendar days.
A certificate check is documentary. It does not tell you whether the policy would respond to a particular claim. For that, read the policy wording or take advice from a broker or lawyer.
How does Vendarity help with insurance evidence?
Vendarity offers an optional “Insurance evidence” starting requirement when you define a requirement. Its review guidance asks the reviewer to confirm the named insured, the policy type and minimum limit, the insurer and the period of cover. You preview and adapt it, publish it, then assign it to suppliers yourself. You can also state the minimum limits your contract requires: the reviewer records each limit the certificate prints, and Vendarity compares the two only in the same currency. And you can list wording the certificate must show, such as additional insured or a waiver of subrogation: the supplier sees it before uploading, and the reviewer records whether the certificate shows it. Vendarity does not judge whether an endorsement is valid.
The reviewer records the insured entity, insurer, policy number and policy dates beside the file. Where AI is switched on, it proposes those fields with page citations as each certificate arrives, for the reviewer to check. Once an Owner or Admin turns on automatic reminders, renewal reminders are planned from the accepted expiry date.
Vendarity records that a person checked the document. It does not assess whether the cover is adequate or whether a claim would be paid. See what Vendarity does and does not do and how Vendarity tracks insurance certificates.
Sources
- Bulletin S-14: use of certificates of insurance (9 November 2010) · Connecticut Insurance Department
- OGC Opinion 08-05-13: certificates of insurance (30 May 2008) · New York State Department of Financial Services
- Guidance note: insurance certificates of currency · Australian Government Department of Defence
- How do I request a certificate of currency for my Small Business Insurance policy? · AA Insurance (New Zealand)
- Employers’ liability insurance · GOV.UK
- Insurance (employers’ liability compulsory insurance) · Health and Safety Executive for Northern Ireland
- Financial Services Register · Financial Conduct Authority
- Operational policy 14-02-04: clearance certificate · Workplace Safety and Insurance Board (Ontario)