Additional insured or certificate holder: the difference

A certificate holder receives information about a policy; an additional insured is covered by it. How each is created, what each gets, and how to check yours.

In short

A certificate holder is the business a certificate of insurance is issued to; an additional insured is a business the policy itself covers, because an endorsement adds it. Being the holder gives you information about the policy, not cover, and by itself no right to be told if it is cancelled. To be covered, ask for the endorsement; to be told of a cancellation, the policy or an endorsement must say so.

A certificate holder is the business a certificate of insurance is issued to. An additional insured is a business the policy itself covers, because an endorsement adds it. Being the holder gives you information about someone else’s policy, not cover under it, and by itself no right to be told if it is cancelled. If your contract says you must be covered, the certificate is not enough: ask for the endorsement.

This is general information, not legal or insurance advice. What protection you need, and what an endorsement gives you, depends on your contract and the policy wording.

What is a certificate holder?

The person or business that asked for evidence of the policy. Connecticut’s Bulletin S-14 says certificates inform “a company or individual who is not a party to the insurance policy-called a Certificate Holder” of the coverages, and that a certificate “confers no rights or benefits upon the third party certificate holder”.

The holder box can’t add rights either. The Texas Department of Insurance says a certificate holder “may not use the ‘Certificate Holder’ box to imply or confer any new or additional rights beyond what the policy or any executed endorsement of insurance provides”.

What is an additional insured?

Someone the policy covers who isn’t the policyholder. Bulletin S-14 says that to receive that protection, a holder “would need to be named an ‘Additional Insured’ by endorsement or by being named an insured under the terms of the underlying policy”, and that “in some cases, there may be a cost for such protection”.

An endorsement may name one business, or be a blanket endorsement. Texas says that where the policy has only a blanket additional insured endorsement, a certificate can say so, but can’t name the holder as an additional insured.

How do the two compare?

Certificate holder and additional insured, side by side
QuestionCertificate holderAdditional insured
How you become oneBy being named in the certificate’s holder boxBy an endorsement to the policy, naming you or describing you
Covered by the policy?NoYes, as far as the endorsement and policy say
Told if the policy is cancelled?Not by being the holder: S-14 says the holder “is owed no duty to be notified”Only if the policy or an endorsement provides it
CostNone“In some cases, there may be a cost” (S-14)

On cancellation notice, ACORD explains that “a typical liability insurance policy obliges an insurer to notify only the first named insured and no one else of policy cancellation, unless the policy is endorsed to provide notice to another party”. Texas says a certificate may promise notice only if the provision mirrors the policy’s own requirements.

How do you check which one you are?

  1. Read the certificate. On an ACORD form, Texas says the Additional Insured box should be checked only “if the policy includes an endorsement that names the certificate holder as an additional insured”.
  2. Ask for the endorsement itself. Texas notes that its certificate law “does not prohibit an agent or insurer from providing a copy of the policy or endorsements”.
  3. Check the endorsement names you, or describes you clearly, and covers the work in your contract.
  4. Keep the endorsement with the certificate, and ask for it again at each renewal, with the new certificate.

Remember why the endorsement matters: ACORD says “only an endorsement, rider, or amendment to the policy can effect changes in coverage”, and a certificate does not “provide, endorse, amend, extend, or alter in any way the terms of an insurance policy”.

Does the same apply to a certificate of currency?

The principle does: a certificate reports a policy and can’t change it. The wording differs between countries and policies. Australian Defence guidance, for example, asks for evidence, where a contract requires it, “that the Commonwealth is insured for its vicarious liability or its interest in insured property is insured under the policy”. It also warns that a certificate issued for a contract “may record only relevant insureds, not all insureds”.

A checklist when your contract requires cover

  • Your contract says exactly what cover you need under the contractor’s policy.
  • The certificate names you as holder, and the additional insured box or wording refers to an endorsement.
  • You hold a copy of the endorsement, and it names or describes you.
  • The endorsement’s period matches the policy period on the certificate.
  • Notice of cancellation, if you need it, is provided in the policy or an endorsement.
  • At renewal, you ask for the new certificate and the new endorsement together.

How does Vendarity help?

In Vendarity you list the wording your contract requires as terms to confirm on the requirement, such as additional insured or a waiver of subrogation, up to eight of them. Contractors see the terms before they upload. At review, the reviewer records whether the document shows each term, with a reason for any it doesn’t, and that record stays in the history. See terms to confirm.

Vendarity doesn’t judge whether an endorsement is valid, read the policy or confirm cover with the insurer. For the rest of the certificate, see what to check on a certificate of insurance.

Sources

  1. Bulletin S-14: use of certificates of insurance (9 November 2010) · Connecticut Insurance Department · read
  2. Certificates of insurance: frequently asked questions (Insurance Code chapter 1811) · Texas Department of Insurance · read
  3. Certificates of Insurance FAQs · ACORD · read
  4. Guidance note: insurance certificates of currency (2014) · Australian Government Department of Defence · read
  1. Guides

    Why contractor insurance certificates lapse mid-contract: lessons from a city audit

    A city audit found cover had run out on 13 of 17 contractors’ certificates before the work was done. What caused it, and the controls that catch it.

    5 min read
  2. Guides

    A reminder schedule that gets certificates renewed without chasing

    Time the first ask to when the renewal can exist, make replying easy, stop when it arrives and hand silence to a person. A schedule built on issuers’ own dates.

    5 min read
  3. Guides

    What to do when a contractor’s certificate expires mid-contract

    First find out whether the cover lapsed or only the paperwork. Then decide under the contract, record why and follow up. The steps, with their sources.

    5 min read

Collect and review supplier documents in one place.

Free for up to 25 suppliers. No card needed.